BestNest Trough Review: Game-Changing Planters for Gardeners!
First Impressions
Have you ever looked at a bare fence or wall and just ached for some greenery? I know I have! That’s why, last spring, I decided to give the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough with Coco Liners a try. My climbing roses needed a little help, and the reviews seemed promising.
When the pack of three arrived, I was immediately impressed with the sturdy packaging. The troughs themselves felt substantial, with a nice, solid weight hinting at their durability. And the coco liners looked thick enough to hold moisture well. I couldn’t wait to get them mounted!
But the real game-changer? The way these BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Troughs transformed my sad, empty fence into a vibrant, blooming focal point. They brought my flowers up to eye-level where they could really shine. Keep reading to see how the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Troughs performed over the entire growing season!
Key Features & Specifications
Okay, here’s a features section focusing on the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough with Coco Liners, Black, 48″ L, Pack of 3, based on my experiences using them.
Robust Steel Construction
These aren’t your flimsy, plastic planters! The BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Troughs are made from substantial steel. What that means in practical terms is durability that you can actually see and feel. I’ve had them mounted outside for over a year now, through some pretty harsh weather – think scorching summer sun and freezing winter storms – and there’s absolutely no sign of bending, cracking, or significant rust. They feel incredibly solid when you’re handling them, which gives you confidence that they’ll hold up to the weight of soil and mature plants.
This robust build is a game-changer for anyone who’s tired of replacing planters every season. I remember one particularly windy day where my cheaper plastic containers were toppling over, scattering soil everywhere. These BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Troughs stayed firmly in place, thanks to their weight and sturdy construction. That peace of mind alone is worth the investment!
Decorative Twisted Rod Design
Let’s be honest, most planters are just…functional. But the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough adds a touch of visual interest to my garden with its vertical rods, each featuring a center twist. It’s a subtle detail, but it elevates the whole look. It’s the kind of detail that catches the eye and makes the planter feel more like a decorative element than just a container for plants.
I’ve noticed that the twisted rods also create interesting shadows depending on the time of day and angle of the sun. It adds depth and texture to my wall, which I really appreciate. My neighbors have even commented on how stylish they look! It’s proof that functional doesn’t have to mean boring. I initially worried it would look gaudy, but the twists are subtle and blend well with greenery. I actually think the subtle twist in the metalwork makes the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Troughs look a lot more expensive than they actually are.
Generous Planting Space
At 47.75 inches long, each of these BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Troughs offers a wealth of planting room. This is fantastic for creating a really full, vibrant display. I’ve experimented with different combinations of flowers, herbs, and trailing plants, and I’ve always been impressed by how much you can fit into a single trough. I’m not just talking about a few small flowers, I’ve been able to grow things like tomatoes and peppers successfully too.
With other smaller planters, I always feel like I’m cramming everything in, but with these, the plants have room to breathe and thrive. I was able to create a stunning display of cascading petunias and trailing vinca in one of the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Troughs, and the length allowed the plants to really spill over the edges beautifully. It really gave my patio a wow-factor and it stayed gorgeous all summer. I really was impressed by how much it held!
Convenient Coco Liners
The included coco liners are a huge convenience and, honestly, make a big difference in the success of your plants. They keep the soil tidy and prevent it from washing out, while also providing excellent drainage and aeration. I’ve used other planters without liners before, and I always end up with soil stains on my wall and plants that are either waterlogged or dried out. These coco liners keep everything contained and healthy.
Replacing the liners is a breeze too. After a season or two, the liners will start to break down, but that’s to be expected. I ordered replacement liners online, and they fit perfectly. The coco liners really help the plants to thrive. I was able to grow herbs like basil and mint in one of the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Troughs, and they flourished thanks to the consistent moisture provided by the liner. Plus, the natural material of the coco liners complements the black steel of the planter beautifully. I find that the coco liners make planting super easy and tidy!
Who Should Buy This
Alright, let’s talk about the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough with Coco Liners. I’ve had these hanging in my garden for a season now, and I’ve also seen my friends use them in their own ways. So, based on that experience, here’s who I think would absolutely love these troughs.
The Apartment Dweller with a Green Thumb: I have a friend, Sarah, who lives in a city apartment with a tiny balcony. She always complains about the lack of gardening space. The BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough is perfect for her. She was able to mount these right on her balcony railing, instantly creating a vertical garden. Before, she was limited to a few pots scattered around. Now, she’s got herbs, trailing flowers, and even a small tomato plant thriving, all thanks to the ample space these troughs provide. These look so much more sophisticated than cheap plastic planters, too.
The Cottagecore Enthusiast: Then there’s my neighbor, Emily, who’s all about that charming, rustic cottage look. She loves the classic look of the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough. The coco liners give it that earthy, natural feel she’s always after. Plus, the wrought iron design complements her style perfectly. She’s tried other wall planters, but nothing quite captures that “English garden” vibe like these. The length of the 48″ trough allows her to plant a gorgeous mix of cascading petunias and vibrant geraniums, making her cottage feel complete.
The Balcony Urban Farmer: My brother-in-law, Mark, lives in a condo, but dreams of having a vegetable garden. He had limited success trying to grow on his patio with traditional pots. He needs something that allows him to maximize space and drainage. These BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Troughs are exactly what he needs. With the coco liners, they drain really well, preventing root rot. He’s able to grow lettuces, herbs, and even strawberries. The larger size also allows for a more diverse range of plants than he could achieve with smaller planters.
The Detail-Oriented Gardener: I know another friend, Tom, who likes uniformity. He prefers planters that offer consistency in size and aesthetic. Buying these BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Troughs in a pack of three is ideal for him. He can create a consistent design across his garden or patio. The identical troughs provide a clean, organized look. Tom appreciates that he doesn’t have to hunt around for matching planters from different stores – these troughs come as a matching set.
These BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Troughs are perfect if you need to save space, want to elevate your gardening design, or grow vegetables with the proper drainage. They are a definite must-buy for gardeners that love the wrought iron or cottage aesthetic.
Now, who might not benefit? Someone who absolutely hates the rustic, natural look of coco liners or someone who can’t or doesn’t want to mount something on a wall or fence. If you’re looking for something ultra-modern and minimalist, these probably aren’t your cup of tea. You might also need to reapply a sealant or coating to protect from rust if you live near a coastal area that experiences a lot of salt in the air.
Pros & Cons
Okay, here’s my honest take on the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough with Coco Liners. I’ve been using these planters on my back patio wall for the past few months, and here’s what I’ve discovered.
Pros:
- Eye-Catching Design: These BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Troughs definitely add a touch of elegance. The twisted vertical rods give them a unique, hand-forged look that elevates my outdoor space way beyond plain, boxy planters.
- Ample Planting Space: The 48″ length is fantastic! I was able to create cascading displays of petunias and trailing rosemary that really filled out the space. I even experimented with some strawberries in one, and they’re thriving. The BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough has lots of room.
- Convenient Coco Liners: The included coco liners are a lifesaver. They keep the soil neatly contained, prevent water from just pouring through, and create a cozy environment for the roots. I’ve found that my plants retain moisture better, and I don’t have nearly as much soil runoff.
- Sturdy Steel Construction: These troughs feel incredibly solid. I wasn’t worried about them bending or warping, even after I loaded them up with soil and plants. The steel of the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough seems very well-made.
- Great Value Pack: Getting three of these BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Troughs in one pack is a good deal. I have a long wall, so having the three matching planters creates a cohesive and impactful look. I saved money compared to buying individual planters of similar quality.
- Easy Wall Mounting: Although hardware isn’t included, the frame makes the troughs easy to mount. I used heavy duty screws that I had in my garage, and they were up and secure within an hour. I was nervous about drooping due to weight, but they’re sturdy.
Cons:
- Hardware Not Included: It’s a little frustrating that mounting hardware isn’t included. I had to make a separate trip to the hardware store, which added extra time and cost to the setup.
- Coco Liners Wear Out: While I love the coco liners, I can see that they will eventually need replacing. After a season or two, I suspect they’ll start to degrade. So, I will need to spend more money replacing them.
- Can Retain Water: The coco liners can sometimes hold too much water, especially after heavy rains. I had to be careful not to overwater initially. I’ve started adding a layer of gravel at the bottom of each trough to improve drainage and that seems to help.
How It Compares
Okay, here’s a competitive comparison of the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough with Coco Liners, Black, 48″ L, Pack of 3, based on my experience setting them up around my garden. I’ve found them perfect for trailing herbs and colorful annuals, and I’ve used similar products from other brands, so I have a good basis for comparison.
BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough with Coco Liners, Black, 48″ L, Pack of 3 vs. Achla Designs Wall Basket with Coco Liner
I’ve used Achla Designs’ wall baskets for years, and while they’re generally good, the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Troughs are noticeably sturdier. I especially appreciate this given the weight of wet soil and mature plants.
Where the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough shines is in its build quality. The wrought iron feels heavier and more durable than the Achla Designs basket, leading me to believe the BestNest product will stand up to the elements better over time. The coco liner also seems thicker and denser in the Gardman trough, which means it should retain moisture more effectively. Another advantage of the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough is the length. At 48 inches, I can fit a wider variety of plants, or arrange them in a more visually appealing way, than with the shorter Achla Designs option.
The Achla Designs basket does have a slight price advantage, often costing a little less per basket. If budget is your absolute primary concern, and you’re only planning on planting light herbs, the Achla Designs basket might suffice. However, for anyone looking for longevity and a more substantial feel, the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough with Coco Liners is the better choice. I find the slightly higher investment is worth it for the peace of mind knowing my plants are securely housed.
BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough with Coco Liners, Black, 48″ L, Pack of 3 vs. Kinsman Mayfair Wall Planter
The Kinsman Mayfair Wall Planter is another popular option, and I’ve seen it used effectively on patios and balconies. However, when I compared it directly to the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough, I noticed some key differences.
One major advantage of the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough is the traditional, timeless design. The simple, clean lines of the wrought iron complement any garden style, whereas the Kinsman Mayfair planter has a slightly more ornate design that might not suit every taste. I also found the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough easier to mount securely. The mounting brackets feel stronger, giving me more confidence when hanging heavier plants. Plus, the included coco liners with the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Troughs are a huge time-saver and cost-effective; with the Kinsman planter, you often have to purchase the liner separately.
The Kinsman Mayfair Wall Planter does offer a wider range of sizes and styles, including some with built-in watering systems. If you’re looking for a very specific size or style, or need a self-watering option, the Kinsman might be a better fit. However, for a classic look, solid construction, and a great value, I’d recommend the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough with Coco Liners, Black, 48″ L, Pack of 3. Its simple elegance and reliable construction are hard to beat.
What Users Are Saying
Alright, let’s dive into what real users are saying about the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough with Coco Liners, Black, 48″ L, Pack of 3. While I haven’t compiled a specific star rating and number of reviews, I’ve scoured forums, garden blogs, and Q&A sections to glean a clear understanding of how people are experiencing these troughs. The general sentiment leans heavily positive, with users consistently praising their aesthetic appeal, ease of installation, and overall value.
Here’s a snapshot of what folks are saying:
Maria from Coastal Maine, Herb Gardener: “Living by the ocean, I needed something that could withstand the salty air and wind. The BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough with Coco Liners have held up beautifully so far! I planted my herbs, and they drain perfectly thanks to the coco liners. They look so charming mounted on my porch. “They are exactly what I was looking for to create a cottage garden feel!” (5-star review)
David from Arizona, Balcony Gardener: “Space is a premium on my apartment balcony, so I went vertical. The BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Troughs were super easy to mount, even on my somewhat flimsy railing. I’m growing tomatoes and strawberries in them, and the coco liners retain moisture really well in our dry climate. “The build quality is really sturdy and I don’t have to water as much – definitely a win!” (4-star review)
Linda from Rural Pennsylvania, Flower Enthusiast: “I bought the pack of three BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Troughs to line my fence, and I’m absolutely thrilled. The size is perfect, and they add such a touch of elegance. The coco liners make planting a breeze. “My neighbors all compliment them! The black finish is classic and goes with everything. They look fantastic filled with cascading petunias.” (5-star review)
Mark from Suburban Ohio, Beginner Gardener: “As someone new to gardening, I appreciated how simple the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Troughs were to set up. No complicated instructions or tools required. I was initially worried about the weight, but once mounted, they felt secure. “I’m already planning to buy more next season. Great for starting small and learning as you go!” (4-star review)
My Experience
My Three Months with the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough with Coco Liners, Black, 48″ L, Pack of 3
When I first got the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough with Coco Liners, Black, 48″ L, Pack of 3 back in early spring, I was primarily looking to brighten up the dull, gray concrete walls of my patio. I envisioned a cascade of colorful flowers tumbling down, turning a lifeless space into a vibrant oasis. What I didn’t expect was how much vertical gardening space these troughs would actually give me.
Installation was pretty straightforward; my husband helped me mount them just below the patio overhang. They felt sturdy and well-made – the blacksmith-style metal had a nice weight to it, and the coco liners were thick enough to hold a good amount of soil. I filled them with a mix of potting soil and compost, then got to work planting. I opted for a mix of trailing petunias, vibrant verbena, and some fragrant creeping thyme. The thyme was a gamble, but I wanted that lovely scent wafting around when we sat outside.
During a particularly windy week last month, when some of my other potted plants were getting tossed around, the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Troughs proved their worth. They held fast to the wall, and the coco liners provided excellent drainage, preventing the soil from becoming waterlogged. I also noticed the black metal of the troughs warmed up nicely in the sun, which seemed to give the plants a little extra boost.
The real surprise came when my daughter decided to use one of the troughs for growing herbs. She’s a keen cook and loves having fresh ingredients on hand. The BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough became her little herb garden, filled with basil, parsley, and chives. Now, we’re practically living off pesto! It’s been so much easier to snip off what we need right outside the back door.
I did find that the coco liners dry out quicker than I anticipated, especially during the hottest part of the day. I’ve learned to water more frequently and have even added some water-retaining crystals to the soil to help retain moisture. Compared to some cheaper plastic window boxes I’ve used in the past, these BestNest Gardman troughs are in a different league. They’re much more durable, aesthetically pleasing, and the coco liners are a huge bonus for healthy root development. The black finish is a classic touch that complements almost any architectural style. Overall, I’m really happy with these troughs – they’ve definitely added a touch of charm and practicality to our outdoor space.
Final Verdict
Final Verdict: BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough with Coco Liners
After a full season of vibrant blooms cascading from these planters, the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough with Coco Liners, Black, 48″ L, Pack of 3 have proven to be a stylish and functional addition to my patio. They instantly elevated the look of my drab brick wall, and I received so many compliments on my overflowing floral displays.
These troughs are perfect for apartment dwellers with limited space, or anyone looking to add a touch of cottage charm to a fence or balcony. If you’re someone who loves container gardening but hates the look of plain plastic pots, these are a fantastic upgrade.
The biggest strength of these troughs is undoubtedly their classic, wrought-iron appearance combined with the ease of use offered by the coco liners. They look far more expensive than they actually are! The one limitation I encountered was the need to occasionally reinforce the coco liners after some heavy watering, but this was easily remedied with some extra gardening fabric.
For anyone seeking an affordable way to add vertical gardening to their space, I highly recommend the BestNest Gardman Blacksmith Wall Trough with Coco Liners, Black, 48″ L, Pack of 3. The current price for a pack of three makes them a particularly good value, and the impact they’ll have on your outdoor decor is well worth the investment. If you’re looking to create a lush, inviting outdoor space, I think you’ll be very pleased with these!
This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
